Why the choice matters
To sell a cloud service to federal agencies, you need a FedRAMP Certification. To sell to state and local governments, many buyers look for GovRAMP status. Both programs rely on an independent assessor to verify your security, and agencies make their decisions from that assessor’s work.
The assessor you choose shapes how the assessment runs, how much of your engineering team’s time it takes, and how the results read to the agencies that rely on them. FedRAMP is also changing: a new 20x path now runs alongside the traditional Rev5 path, and the two work very differently. Your assessor needs to know both.
This guide covers what to check, what to ask, and what to be cautious about. It applies to any assessor you are considering.
What a FedRAMP Independent Assessment Service is, and how to verify one
For FedRAMP, the American Association for Laboratory Accreditation (A2LA) manages the accreditation process on behalf of the FedRAMP PMO, accrediting firms to ISO/IEC 17020 standards. Accredited firms are designated as a FedRAMP Recognized Independent Assessment Service (formerly known as a Third Party Assessment Organization, or 3PAO). GovRAMP relies on these same A2LA-accredited, FedRAMP-recognized 3PAOs. These firms independently assess cloud service offerings on behalf of federal agencies for FedRAMP, or state, local, tribal, and educational agencies for GovRAMP.
Accredited assessors must maintain a documented quality management system and demonstrate ongoing technical proficiency, undergoing regular A2LA audits to retain their accreditation.
To verify an assessment firm:
- Check the FedRAMP Marketplace: Search the Assessors tab to confirm the firm is FedRAMP Recognized and in good standing (not listed as in “Remediation”).
- Confirm GovRAMP alignment: Verify the firm meets GovRAMP’s A2LA and FedRAMP requirements, or check GovRAMP’s 3PAO Members directory.
- Request accreditation proof: Ask to review the firm’s current A2LA certificate and scope of accreditation.
A FedRAMP Independent Assessment Service (formerly a 3PAO) is not the same as a CMMC C3PAO. The two programs have separate requirements and separate oversight.
Independence: assessing and advising are separate roles
A FedRAMP Independent Assessment Service can work in one of two capacities for a given cloud service provider: assessment or advisory. In the advisory role, an Independent Assessment Service helps a provider prepare, for example by advising on technical solutions or architecture changes. In the assessment role, it plans the assessment, tests the cloud service offering, and reports the results.
To maintain independence, an advisory Independent Assessment Service cannot perform assessment services for a provider it advised.
When you evaluate an assessor, ask directly whether the firm has advised on, designed, or operated the service it would assess. If you want outside help preparing, that help and your assessor need to be different firms.
FedRAMP 20x and traditional Rev5
A cloud service offering pursues one path or the other, not both. The FedRAMP PMO will stop accepting applications for new FedRAMP Rev5 certifications on June 11, 2027. FedRAMP 20x is the path that stays open for new offerings.
| FedRAMP 20x | Traditional Rev5 | |
|---|---|---|
| Basis | Key Security Indicators (KSIs) and FedRAMP rules | NIST SP 800-53 Rev. 5 controls plus FedRAMP enhancements |
| Assurance tiers | Certification Classes A, B, and C (Class D not yet available) | Low, Moderate, and High baselines |
| Evidence | Machine-readable, automated validation, live demonstration, and historical metrics | Narrative documentation, screenshots, interviews, and technical testing |
| Assessor work products | Per-rule and per-KSI summaries for the Security Decision Record, a Certification Package summary, and JSON results | Security Assessment Plan (SAP), security requirements traceability matrix (SRTM), Risk Exposure Table (RET), and Security Assessment Report (SAR) |
| Ongoing | Annual independent assessment (Class B and higher) | Annual assessment and continuous monitoring |
| New applications | Open | Close June 11, 2027 |
On 20x, the assessor tests both your security capability and the automation that measures it. That takes a different skill set from narrative control testing: reviewing repositories, pipelines, infrastructure as code, and identity systems, and re-performing automated validations. Ask how the firm does that work.
If you already have a SOC 2 Type II, a GovRAMP assessment, or a FedRAMP Rev5 result from the past 12 months, you meet the prerequisite for 20x Class A. A firm that performs both SOC 2 examinations and FedRAMP assessments can speak to both.
GovRAMP statuses and the assessor’s role
GovRAMP, formerly StateRAMP, serves state and local government buyers. It was modeled on the traditional FedRAMP approach and verifies cloud services against NIST SP 800-53, with its own program office and control enhancements.
| Status | What it means | Who verifies it |
|---|---|---|
| Progressing | Entry point; a 40-control Progressing Security Snapshot | The GovRAMP PMO reviews the evidence |
| Core | 60 foundational controls in place, plus 90 days of continuous monitoring data | The GovRAMP PMO reviews the evidence |
| Ready | 3PAO-attested validation of 80 foundational controls (plus PMO validation) | An accredited 3PAO attests |
| Authorized | Authorization to Operate after a full assessment by a 3PAO (300+ controls) | A state or local agency, or the GovRAMP PMO |
GovRAMP requires two assessor deliverables: the SAP and the SAR (which includes a penetration test and vulnerability scans). A Readiness Assessment Report (RAR) is optional. A GovRAMP Ready or authorized assessment from the past 12 months also meets the FedRAMP 20x Class A prerequisite.
What drives scope and effort
When comparing proposals, make sure each firm sized the same scope.
- Leveraged providers. How many IaaS or PaaS providers your service runs on, and whether they are FedRAMP certified.
- The boundary. On 20x, your Certification Class and the Minimum Assessment Scope. On Rev5, your authorization boundary and impact level.
- Mobile applications. Whether mobile apps are part of the scope.
- Thick client applications. Whether installed desktop or client software is part of the scope.
- Automation on 20x. How many validation methods per KSI, and how much historical metric data your class requires.
A proposal that seems much smaller than others may reflect a different reading of your scope. Ask each firm what it assumed.
After certification
A FedRAMP Certification is maintained, not earned once, so you are choosing an assessor for the years after the initial assessment too.
- Annual assessment. On Rev5, the Independent Assessment Service performs an annual assessment, including penetration testing, vulnerability scanning, and testing of a subset of controls. On 20x, Class B and higher require an annual independent assessment of all applicable rules and KSIs.
- POA&M closure. Where a fix can’t be validated by automated means such as a vulnerability scan, an Independent Assessment Service must validate that the finding was corrected.
- Significant changes. Significant changes to the system can require an assessment before they are made.
- New rules. The Vulnerability Detection and Response and Vulnerability Evaluation and Reporting rules take effect for all FedRAMP Certifications on December 7, 2026, with a grace period ending March 7, 2027.
Once your offering is certified, other agencies can rely on that result. FedRAMP is designed as a “do once, use many times” program on both paths.
Red flags
None of these alone settles the question, but each one deserves a direct answer:
- It isn’t on the FedRAMP Marketplace or can’t show its A2LA accreditation.
- It offers to prepare you and then assess you. An advisory Independent Assessment Service cannot assess a provider it advised.
- It guarantees a certification. No assessor can promise an outcome before testing.
- It only knows one path. If it can’t explain how 20x differs from Rev5, it may steer you to the path it knows rather than the one that fits.
- It treats 20x like a Rev5 assessment with fewer controls. 20x evidence is machine-readable and automated, and the assessor tests the automation.
- It confuses FedRAMP with CMMC or GovRAMP. The programs have separate requirements and oversight, and mixing up their artifacts wastes time.
- It can’t tell you who will be on your team.
12 questions to ask any assessor
Bring the same list to every call so the answers can be compared side by side.
- Are you listed on the FedRAMP Marketplace, and can we see your A2LA accreditation?
- Are you an approved GovRAMP 3PAO?
- Have you advised on, designed, or operated the service you would assess?
- Which path do you recommend for us, 20x or Rev5, and why?
- On 20x, how do you test our automated KSI validations and historical metrics?
- On Rev5, what goes into your SAP, SRTM, RET, and SAR?
- Who will be on our team, and what are their backgrounds in cloud architecture and security testing?
- How do you handle our leveraged IaaS or PaaS providers?
- How do you raise findings during the assessment, and how often?
- Do we review the results with you before anything goes to an agency or program office?
- What does the annual assessment involve, and do you perform it?
- What assumptions did you make about our scope when preparing your proposal?